| Solar energy is a plentiful resource in virtually all climates.
Although in the winter in the far north or cloudy areas have a much
reduced solar gain, there is still significant gain even in cloudy places
like Seattle. Solar energy has the environmental advantage of not
producing any waste products, although in the case of solar electric, we
can't completely ignore the impact of creating the solar cells themselves
(which often contain toxic chemicals).
There are many ways to take advantage of solar energy, some very simple
and low cost and others relatively expensive. At present solar
electric is quite expensive, even when averaged over the lifetime of the
system, but like any other electronic product engineering could bring the
price down dramatically. Meanwhile, passive solar design has become
standard practice for many designers. Early passive solar houses used a
large quantity of glass on the south side, creating somewhat of a
space-age look. It is now more common to use only a moderate amount
of glass, allowing just about any style home to take advantage of passive
solar energy. Due to its complexity and cost, active solar has taken
the backseat to passive solar, but is still the method of choice for solar
water heating.
Due to its low cost and effectiveness in virtually all climates, every
home should incorporate passive solar design to some degree unless shading
makes it impossible.
Determining how much solar you have
The amount of solar energy striking your home at any given
time is determined by the length of time the sun is up, the angle of the
sun, the degree of cloud cover and the shading due to anything blocking
the sun during the day. The farther north you go, the less solar
gain you have available in the winter when you need it, but luckily there
is still usually enough. Homes located on a north facing slope often
have much less available gain due to the shading of the slope itself, and
so the ideal location is either fairly flat or south facing.
Calculating your available gain involves looking up solar gain and weather
data for your location in a chart, and is beyond the scope of this
discussion. (See references)
Thermal
Mass: Storing heat for when the sun isn't out
It is almost impossible to think about solar energy without thinking about
thermal mass because the sun is only out during the day when there are no
clouds. While it is always possible to resort to using burning fuel
when the sun isn't available, even a small amount of thermal mass will
allow us to store enough of a day's heat to reduce fuel use.
The two significant properties of a thermal mass material is how much
heat it will store per cubic foot of space and how fast can be get heat in
and out of the material. The most common materials to store heat in
are concrete, rocks and water, with concrete being by far the most common
one because it can also be an integral part of the building. Water
stores the most heat per cubic foot and also transfers heat the fastest
(due to convection within the water), but has the property that it tends
to eventually leak and cause damage. Concrete and rocks have almost
as good a heat storage ability, but move heat very slowly, although this
can be sped up by directly heating the stone (i.e. paint it dark color and
let the sun shine on it directly), and by increasing the surface area to
improve conduction.
In all cases, thermal mass will act to try to keep the house at
temperature of the mass by either absorbing heat or giving off heat,
limited only to the speed in which heat transfers in and out of the
material (which itself is dependent on surface area). The more
thermal mass a house has, the harder it is to change it's
temperature. Think of thermal mass as a holding tank with a fixed
size pipe going into it. The properties of the mass are determined
by the size of the tank and the size of the opening. If a large
thermal mass is used and house reaches a temperature outside the comfort
range, its very difficult to get the house back to a comfortable
temperature because the mass will resist any changes.
In order to store heat (or cool) a mass must be a different temperature
than the air temperature, and the greater the difference the more heat it
will hold, so there is a practical limit to how much heat the mass can
store (due to a variety of practical reasons: e.g. in the case of storing
heat in the floor, we don't want our floors too hot!) Thermal mass
is typically designed only to hold enough heat to get through a short cold
period: anywhere from overnight to a couple of cloudy days, thereby
avoiding the problems of not being able to heat or cool the house when for
some reason it gets either too hot or too cold. Even a small thermal
mass system can take an uncomfortably long time to reach a comfortable
temperature if allowed to get too hot or cold.
Methods of Collecting Solar Energy
Passive Solar
Passive solar refers to methods of collecting the heat energy of
the sun without using any moving parts. In its simplest form,
passive solar is just a matter of orienting the house so that its longest
side faces south, and putting most of the windows on the south side,
called a direct gain system. As an alternative to having windows on the south side,
a south facing greenhouse (sunroom) can be attached to the house, or other
variety of indirect gain system could be built into the south
wall. Each method has it own set of advantages.
(typical room layout for passive)
(overhang diagram)
Direct Gain
In the simple direct gain system, the home is designed so that there
is a long side facing south and put the majority of our windows
there. Because people generally want our bedrooms cooler and out
public spaces warmer, the kitchen, dining and living room are put on the
south side (see figure), although other layouts are certainly
possible. The south facing windows are then shaded by overhangs so
that when the sun is high in the summer it is blocked by the overhang, but
when it's low in the winter it passes below the overhang. As a rule
of thumb, the amount of south facing windows should equal about 10-15% of
the floor area of the house.
It is difficult to use east or west facing windows for solar gain
because the sun is always low in the sky no matter what the season, so you
get too much heat in the summer. In northern areas, the sun stays
far the south all day, further reducing the amount of gain.
To correctly determine the amount of windows needed, a heat loss
calculation should first be done to determine how much heat is needed, the
subtract off that amount the internal gain of the house (the waste
heat produced by appliances) to determine how much heat is needed.
Using a chart (available in most books on passive solar, see
references), then determine how much energy is reaching the house in
each month (taking into account the shading we add to the windows).
Dividing the total needed by the amount by the amount reaching the house
in a day gives the total amount of solar needed. Often a house is
designed so that it gets most of its heat from the sun on a average winter
day, but requires burning some fuel on colder or cloudier days.
Determining the exact performance of the house is difficult, and often
done with the aid of a software package.
There are often seasonal difficulties in direct gain systems, because
the sun is at the same place in the sky at both equinoxes, on Mar 21 and
Sept 21, but the weather is much colder in March than it is in
September. There are two good ways to deal with this: using
deciduous plants (such as trellis with grapes on it) or an exterior
movable screen that increases the overhang. The degree that extra
gain is a problem depends on the climate and the amount of solar gain the
house has.
Solar gain is also affected by the angle the sun strikes the window and
the properties of the window itself. Ideally the house should face
directly south, but in practice anywhere with 10-15 degrees of south gets
good results. In the past solar houses were designed with windows
tilted off vertical so that they would be exactly perpendicular to the winter
sun, but a normal vertically mounted vertical window will perform nearly as well. The
most significant effect is that of the kind of glass itself: if Low-E
glass is used, it should be of the variety that has a high solar heat gain
coefficient (see windows)
In cities where existing lots have not been laid out with solar in
mind, direct gain solar systems can be difficult of impossible. The
most desirable lots have no obstructions of the sun and have streets
running in the E/W directions so that either the front or the back of the
house faces south. When the neighborhood isn't designed for solar,
the south face of the house may not have privacy, and so putting windows
there can be a problem.
(figures: trombe
wall, greenhouse, thermosiphon trombe, thermosiphon below to rock bin)
Indirect Gain
In an indirect gain system, the sun passes through glass and heats an
air space that is connected in some way to allow heat to pass into the
house. In a Trombe wall (named after French inventor Felix
Trombe) or water wall, the a large mass is placed very close to the
glass (either concrete or barrels of water) and the sun then heats the
mass which then radiates its heat through the other side to the
house. In a greenhouse the sun heats the air in a room and the air
is then moved into the house either via convection or a fan. Typically a greenhouse
is attached to the main house via an exterior door, so that the room can
be closed off to prevent heat loss at night and on cold cloudy days.
A variation on both systems is a thermosiphon wall where a small
air space is heated by the sun and the rising warm air moved by convection
into the house (see figures).
All indirect gain systems have the advantage of separating the
solar collector from the homes windows, allowing flexibility in design for
locations that aren't well suited to direct gain. Because the
collector is all in one spot, it takes less effort to control both
overheating and cold weather heat loss because only one set of
doors/shutters must be closed, although most people do not want to have to
open and close shutters on a regular basis.
In a mass wall system like the Trombe wall, the wall is a very poor
insulator and so is a liability during prolonged cold cloudy periods and
on cold nights. It also has a long time lag, it may take hours
before the sun hitting the outside of the masonry reaches into the home
(ideal for mild, sunny winters but otherwise a liability). Likewise,
a greenhouse requires owner intervention daily and must be highly vented
in the summer to prevent overheating. Thermosiphon systems are
easier on the homeowner, but care must be taken to prevent reverse
thermosiphoning, where the heat of the house is removed by convection at
night. As in all systems, better engineering can conquer many of the
problems of each system, and no system is prefect.
Designing Passive Solar Homes
Passive solar homes are conceptually easy to design, but getting
the details right can be quite difficult.
- Determine your system type - depending on your lot, climate,
budget and personal preferences, pick which kind of system you want to
use.
- Home orientation - orienting your home to the south makes
life easier in all solar collection systems, but all that is critical
is that the solar collection area be facing south.
- Floorplan - determine how your solar collection will
integrate into the rest of the home. Its is generally more
important to have warm common spaces than warm bedrooms.
- Overhangs & Overheating - design overhangs to avoid
overheating in the summer, which still allowing for solar collection
in the spring. In many climates and external screen will also be
necessary.
- Daylighting - beware of excessive daylight created by a large
solar collection area.
- Thermal mass - depending on how cloudy your climate is,
design at least one full days worth of heat storage into the home, but
beware of putting too much heat storage in.
- Sizing your system - determine the amount of glass you need
by know your heat loss, internal gain (from appliances), and average
amount of solar gain available. Since weather varies significantly,
you will often design for the typical conditions, using backup heat
during periods of extreme cold.
Active Solar
In an active solar system we separate the solar collector from the
house, and use electricity to move the heat into the house. The
collector consists of a sheet of glass covering an airspace in which a
specially coated black metal surface collects upward of 90% of the solar
energy hitting it. Inside the collector, the black metal either
heats the air itself, or a fluid (typically including anti-freeze for cold
nights). In the more efficient versions, the metal is water running
through it and the air is removed, significantly reducing the heat loss
back outside.
(picture: active solar collector & pumps)
Once the solar is collected it can then either be distributed directly
to the rooms in the house or stored in a thermal
mass such as a rock bin or a radiant slab (see heat
distribution). Due to the cost and complexity of active solar,
it has less popular than passive, although it is still the only method of
choice for water heating. Compared to
passive methods, active solar allows much more architectural flexibility
due to only needing to find a place for the collection panels.
Often the solar collectors are on the roof, but they can also be built
into a south facing wall or even detached somewhat from the house
(although distance will create extra avenues for heat loss).
One interesting variant of active solar is to use a very large (and
also very well insulated!) rock bin and store heat in it all summer long
to be used as reserve heat in the winter. Such a system is ideal for
locations where winter has extended periods of cold and clouds, but summer
is warm and has ample sunshine. Another variant stores heat in a
much thicker than normal slab, but uses air instead of water to distribute
the heat (thereby avoid any potentially water problems). Active
solar systems are also easy to back up with various furnaces and heat
distribution systems.
Solar (Photovoltaic) Electric
On an initial cost basis, solar electric remains out of many
people budgets, although in areas with higher costs for electric, they can
pay off over their lifetimes. However, the availability of subsidies or
tax breaks can make solar electric affordable, and with the on-going
research and improvement in manufacturing, the price of the solar cells
themselves is expected to go down dramatically.
Solar electric systems come in two basic varieties: those connected to
the power grid and those not connected (off-grid). The
off-grid systems are the currently the major supporters of solar electric
because the initial cost of connecting to the power grid is often higher
than installing solar electric. Grid connected systems are
becoming more common as states and utilities offer both rebates to help
cover the initial cost and net metering laws, in which utilities
buy back excess electric generated by your solar electric system, making
it so you can use the power grid as a battery. Note that the
utilities will not actually pay you for excess electric, but simply
subtract it from the total you use, with any excess beyond your month's
usage going to the utility for free. Check with your utility to find its
exact rules.
Both kinds of systems consist of three components:
- Solar cells, which turn sunlight into direct current
electric, typically 12 volts, the same as car batteries. Solar
cells come in three varieties themselves, single crystal, polysilicon,
and amorphous, in general order of decreasing both the electric
conversion efficiency and cost. The power generation ability of
a solar cell is given in watts, and is the power it can generate at
maximum sunlight, and often only as long as the cell itself stays
under a maximum temperature. Solar cells are usually sold in panels
and rated for their maximum output, so for the most part the type of
solar cell can be ignored. Lower efficiency cells will require
more panels, and hence more roof area to generate the same power, and
so may not be cheaper per generated watt than a higher efficiency
unit.
- Inverters turn the low voltage DC electric generated
by the solar cells and convert it to the 120 Volts AC that is the
standard plug power in the United States. In doing so, the
inverter uses some of the power generated by the solar cell to run
itself, and so lowers the overall efficiency of the system. Some
people circumvent this problem by buying special 12Volt DC appliances
and running special heaving gauge wire required by 12 Volt DC
wiring. Since both are more expensive, there is a point where it
is cheaper to just buy extra solar cells, and as the cost of those
cells goes down, the use of 12 volt DC appliances is likely to
disappear altogether. Since many appliances are only available
in 120 Volt AC versions, virtually every system will have an
inverter. For those who are connecting to the power grid, a special
inverter is used.
- Batteries store excess power for use when there is no
other. In an off-grid system, this is anytime the sun isn't
shining, and so those systems usually need a large (and expensive)
bank of batteries. In a system connected to the power grid,
batteries aren't needed at all, and are only used for those who want a
backup power source during power outages, which can be a significant
feature if your home experiences frequent power outages. Typical
batteries are just an improved version of car batteries, and are both
expensive, short lived (5-8 years) and easy to ruin. There are
unfortunately no good batteries out there, and none are likely to be
available in the near future.
In addition to these main components, a system requires racks to hold
the solar panels and wiring to link it all together. The overall
efficiency of the system can be improved somewhat by installing the solar
cells on tracking racks, which follow the sun during the day.
How much electric you generate will depend on the same criteria that
all solar power does: how many clear days you get, how long the sun is up,
whether the solar cells avoid shaded and whether they are facing the sun
directly (with true south being the best if tracking mounts are not
used). Solar electric systems are rated by their maximum output, and
are typically somewhere between a half a kilowatt to six kilowatts, with
systems in the 1-2 kilowatt range being generally adequate for a house
with a reasonable amount of electric appliances. For example a 1kw
system that receives 5 hours of full sunshine a day will generate 5kwh of
electric in a day, while a 2kw system getting the same 5 hours will
generate 10kwh a day.
To determine how much electric you need, look at how much electric you
use from a current electric bill and divide by the number of days to get
the amount of power used in one day. If your house has electric hot water,
and electric stove or other large power users, you will find that even if
you are very conservative, you will use a very large amount of
electric. For example it takes about 3.5kwh to heat 30 gallons
of water, which is a typical amount of hot-water to use in a day (although
an experienced water miser can do much better!).
For a more conservative number, take the power rating of all your
appliances ignoring hot water, electric stoves and electric heaters and
multiply each one's power rating by how many hours a day that appliance
will be used to get the total power used (in kilowatt-hours).
For example a 800watt blow dryer used 5 minutes a day uses only about
.07kwh, while a top energy star refrigerator uses about 1.2kwh a day, and
a 200w computer on for four hours a day uses .8kwh a day. When
they are all added up, it is often the case that a 1-2kw system producing
between 4 and 10kwh a day is of adequate size.
Cost
Solar system costs can vary much, and like any other product, the
costs change over time. As a ballpark estimate, a solar electric
system costs anywhere from $6000 to $10,000 per 1kw installed, with
grid-connected systems being at the much cheaper end due to having no or
very few batteries. Larger systems lower the cost somewhat, although
the cost of the solar panels is fixed.
Lifetime & Reliability
While single crystal and polysilicon cells should last a long
time-at least 30 years, amorphous cells have a tendency to lose efficiency
over time resulting in lower power output.
BIPV Systems
Building Integrated PhotoVoltaic systems integrate the
solar cells into a building material, thereby lowering the overall cost
somewhat. While this technique is generally used in large commercial
construction, there are two roofing products intended for home use, both
using amorphous cell mounted on a roofing material: metal roofing in one
case, and asphalt composition roofing in the other. Anyone
considering these systems should check their expected lifetimes with the
manufacturer.
Solar Electric & Sustainability
Most solar electric systems are sized to be the minimum acceptable
due to the initial high system cost, forcing homeowners to use other
methods for hot water, cooking and space heating and cooling. With
combinations of passive and active solar, most space heating and cooling
as well as hot water can be provided, but often some kind of backup is
needed, and just as often that backup is either natural gas or propane.
Historically, this compromise has been acceptable, but as the price of
solar cells comes down, it begins to make more sense to use solar electric
as the backup power, because unlike fossil fuels it can be produced sustainably.
(But of course sustainability is always a complex analysis: we must
include the energy to produce the solar cell, and we can't ignore
alternative ways of producing "natural gas", for example a
bio-gas generator using cow manure as a fuel is certainly sustainable).
Passive Cooling
Passive cooling is not really related to solar power, but is generally
grouped with it because it is a technique that uses no fuel. In
passive cooling, the principle of hot air rising is taken advantage of by
putting vents as high in the house as possible (the higher the vent, the
larger the air flow), often in an opening skylight. As long as the
night time air is cooler than the house temperature this technique works
very effectively. By designing good cross ventilation, further cooling can
be achieved if there is at least a light breeze outside.
If periods of hot weather are short, the thermal mass of the house will
absorb some of the extra heat, but beware of letting a house with thermal
mass get too warm as it will not cool off quickly. Since the
ground temperature in most areas stays relatively cool (typically below 60
degrees), we can use the ground as a thermal mass also by using a pipe
under the house to draw cold air out of the ground. Transferring too
much heat will cause heating of the ground around the pipe, rendering it
as ineffective as any other thermal mass, so the usual cautions apply.
When the relative humidity is low, passive cooling can be increased by
evaporating water (such as the cooling towers used in the middle eastern
countries), which takes advantage of the additional heat absorbed by the
evaporating water. Obviously if water is scarce this would be a bad
technique. Sometimes no passive technique works and we have to resort to
air conditioning.
Resouces
Passive Solar Energy, Second edition, Bruce Anderson &
Malcom Wells, Brick House Publishing 1994.
A good introductory guide.
The Solar Home Book, Bruce Anderson & Michael Riordan,
Cheshire Books, 1976
Out of print, but still available used, this is a good in-depth book.
The Passive Solar Energy Book, Edward Mazria, Rodale Press, 1979
Possibly out of print, but generally available as a used book.
The Passive Solar House, James Kachadorian, Chelsea Green, 1997.
Although empasising only one kind of solar system (designed by the
author), the basic principles are there also.
The New Solar Electric Home, Joel Davidson, AATC publications
1987.
http://www.eren.doe.gov/erec/factsheets/passive_solar.html
Web site from the department of energy, covering about the same
material as is covered here.
http://www.consumerenergycenter.org/homeandwork/homes/construction/solardesign.html
The California Energy commission solar design tutorial, also covering
similar material to this one.
|