sensible house
  Home Theory Topics Case Studies About Resources Contact  
 
Building Codes and Prescriptive Solutions 
Building codes are laws created by governments to ensure minimal levels of health, safety and performance.  Historically most of these codes addressed only safety and simple health issues.  Houses had to meet a level of structural integrity so they would survive normal "severe" weather and usage conditions: a house that meets code will support a room full of people, survive a big snow storm, live through the average hurricane, etc.  Fire regulations help prevent it from burning down and electrical code keeps the wiring safe.  In addition the health department keeps the water clean and prevents sewage from infecting anything.  The energy crisis brought about energy codes, and the resulting mold & toxics problems brought about ventilation codes. 

All these laws have a common thread: they are "one size fits all" solutions.  Although many codes allow for the possibility of unique solutions that still meet the underlying safety or performance concern, in practice it is often difficult to get those past unless the building inspector is open to those possibilities.   As more people use alternative techniques and materials, inspectors become more familiar and hence more open to allowing them.  As we will see, the very nature of Green Building is to design with basic principles in mind rather than using a "one size fits all" approach.

A parallel effort to set a standard for Green Building has been created by a number of organizations: in the United States principally by local home building organizations (all affiliated with the National Association of Home Builders) and by The US Green Building Council, a non-profit organization.  In all cases there is an attempt to quantify how green a building actually is.  The simplest, and currently the most common method for home building is to use a checklist of green features and count how many of them are applied, while the more complex methods are what we call "performance based", meaning that one has to put an actually number on how different the building is from standard.

To give an example: in the prescriptive (or checklist) approach, a builder might say "insulated beyond code", "used advance framing", "used energy-star appliances" etc, while in the performance based approach, the builder must say exactly how much energy is expected to be saved versus standard building.

While all these rules and rating systems are a step in the right direction, Green Building's general principal are to start first principles, and so any performance based system is always preferable.